Opal Telecom / HUTCHISON 3G UK LTD / Appellants Everything Everywhere Ltd / LTD (3) VODAFONE LTD / BT Services / WordWave International Limited / S J Berwin LLP / Appellant Telefónica O2 UK Ltd / Herbert Smith LLP / Everything Everywhere Ltd / Cable & Wireless / TELEFÓNICA O2 UK LTD / Vodafone Ltd / BRITISH TELECOMMUNICATIONS PLC / Mackenzie LLP / Merrill Communications Company / /
Country
United Kingdom / /
Event
Business Partnership / /
Facility
COURT OF APPEAL / /
IndustryTerm
recipient use different networks / public communications networks / electronic communications networks / fixed network / telephone users / retail charge / networks / communications service / call hosting services / electronic communications services / communications providers / information technology sectors / agreed solution / number translation services / transmission networks / mobile operator / mobile phone network / mobile telephone / electronic communications / mobile telephone network operators / connection services / telecommunications / public electronic communications network / competition law remedies / network operator / fixed network services / transit services / fixed network telephone number / electronic communications service / /
OperatingSystem
MNOs / /
Organization
office of Communications Hearing / COMPETITION APPEAL TRIBUNAL / CP (TCP) / office of Communications / national regulatory authority / COURT OF APPEAL / European Union / BRITISH TELECOMMUNICATIONS PLC OFFICE OF COMMUNICATIONS Appellants Respondent Interested Party / BT’s NCCN / CIVIL DIVISION / /
Person
MARCUS SMITH / Philip Woolfe / Notice / Graham Read / Sarah Lee / PAUL STONEMAN / Richard Eschwege / LLOYD LORD / Javan Herberg / Jon Turner / Mark Vinall / Jonathan Crow / PETER CLAYTON / / /
Position
Counsel for their able and clear submissions / Official / PROFESSOR / /
ProgrammingLanguage
EC / /
Technology
information technology / mobile phones / cellular telephone / CAT / /
Neutral Citation Number: [2012] EWCA Civ 1002 Case Nos: C3, 3124, 3315, 3316 andIN THE COURT OF APPEAL (CIVIL DIVISION) ON APPEAL FROM THE COMPETITION APPEAL TRIBUNAL MARCUS SMITH Q.C., PETER CLAYTON