Columbo Pete Seigmund Jim / Mike Woods Brett Woody / Manny Mendoza Toby Thompson Bert / Sean Cranmer Gary Dahlgren Anthony / William Grove Justin Trodick / Toby Thompson Bert Smith Shawn / Shawn Borgen Sean Cranmer Gary / Bert Smith Shawn Borgen Sean / Jim Reuter Manny Mendoza Toby / Woods Brett Woody Ty Columbo Pete Seigmund / David Pemble William Grove Justin / Anthony Butterfield David Pemble William / Gary Dahlgren Anthony Butterfield David / Isaac Hall Darren Borgen Mike / / /