Taylor Jo Shepardson Emily Eskridge Shayne / Taylor Jo Shepardson Tyra Murry Emily / Tyra Murry Emily Eskridge Shayne / Amy Dew / Elizabeth Woodall Jana / Dillon Wooten Tori Duke Carra / Mary Helen Bullard / Jessie Mullin / Conley Winslow Baylee Wooten Hannah Denton Sherri / Jessy Bateman / Emily Eskridge Shayne Forrester Hannah / Tori Duke Evelyn Green Courtney Hyman Amy / Amber Hinnant Sandy Black / Courtney Hyman Jana / Elizabeth Woodall Abby Brown Tori / Dew Brenna / Hannah Denton Baylee Wooten Jarrett Privette / Brenna Warner / Abby Brown Tori Duke Evelyn / Sherri Crumpler / Tori Duke Carra Lane Merindy Piland / Shayne Forester / Lane Merindy Piland Courtney Hyman / Shayne Forrester Hannah Denton / Elizabeth Woodall Dillon Wooten Tori / /