Boston / Radnor / King of Prussia / Philadelphia / Phoenix / Chicago / /
Company
BMW / Fenner & Smith Inc. / Defendant National City Bank / THE PNC FINANCIAL SERVICES GROUP INC. / Bank of N. Va. / Merrill Lynch / NATIONAL CITY CORP. / N. Am. LLC / Wal-Mart Stores Inc. / NATIONAL CITY BANK / /
statistical tool / counseling and other services / law common / /
Organization
Supreme Court / United States District Court / US Federal Reserve / /
Person
JOANN RAMOS / Eduardo C. Robreno / JOHN RODRIGUEZ / Joseph H. Meltzer Donna / Nat / JENNIFER WORTHINGTON / Edward W. Ciolko Joseph / Donna S. Moffa Peter / Amanda R. Trask Kessler / Rosa Maria Conchas / Neal / Peter A. Muhic / LUIS RAMOS / David H. Pittinsky / ROSE MARIA CONCHAS / JESUS CONCHAS / BOBBY CROUTHER / Ballard Spahr / /
Position
Counsel / Circuit Judge / circuit clerk / loan officer / Counsel for Respondents / specific supervisor / District Judge / FISHER / /
PRECEDENTIAL UNITED STATES COURT OF APPEALS FOR THE THIRD CIRCUIT ______ No______